Get more tokens, every trade

Competitor Tests – Why Altcoinist Wins

🏆 The Bottom Line

Altcoinist delivers 2–16x better execution than competitors.


What was tested:

  • 7 trading platforms (Altcoinist, Maestro, BasedBot, Sigma, Banana Gun, Uniswap, MetaMask)

  • 400+ trades across 5 test rounds over 2 months

  • 6 different tokens: VIRTUALS, AERO, ALTT, EDGE, SQDGN, TIBBIR

  • 5 trade sizes: 0.01 ETH, 0.05 ETH, 0.1 ETH, 0.2 ETH, 0.5 ETH

Methodology: Pure execution quality measured as percentage deviation between expected and actual tokens/ETH received, adjusted for platform fees. Lower is better.

Fee Treatment: All Telegram bots charge ~1% trading fee. Uniswap charges 0.25%, MetaMask charges 0.875%. Our execution measurements isolate the slippage/routing quality BEYOND these fees for fair comparison.

Based on 400+ independent trades. Full data available for verification.

Available here → Competitor Test Databases


🎯 Execution Quality: Altcoinist Dominates

How much value does each platform lose beyond their stated fee? Lower execution loss = better routing.

Platform

Execution Score

vs Altcoinist

Win Rate

🥇 Altcoinist

100/100

Baseline

74%

🥈 Maestro

59/100

1.7x worse

67%

🥉 MetaMask

38/100

2.6x worse

61%

4th - BasedBot

22/100

4.5x worse

41%

5th - Sigma

18/100

5.6x worse†

59%

6th - Uniswap

8/100

12x worse†

59%

7th - Banana Gun

6/100

16x worse

24%

† Sigma and Uniswap scores adjusted for trades they couldn't complete due to routing failures


💵 The 74% Win Rate

What percentage of trades execute with minimal slippage (<0.5% execution loss)? Higher = more consistent quality.

Platform

Trades <0.5% Loss

Win Rate

Gap to Altcoinist

Altcoinist

50 of 68

74%

Maestro

24 of 36

67%

-7%

MetaMask

22 of 36

61%

-13%

Sigma

40 of 68

59%

-15%

Uniswap

19 of 32

59%

-15%

BasedBot

29 of 70

41%

-33%

Banana Gun

16 of 68

24%

-50%


📉 Catastrophic Loss Rate: The Risk You Don't See

How often does each platform badly fail? These are trades where routing went wrong, costing you 3%, 5%, or even 10%+ beyond the platform fee.

Platform

3%+ Loss

5%+ Loss

10%+ Loss

Worst Trade

Altcoinist

0.0%

0.0%

0.0%

No trade over 2%

MetaMask

0.0%

0.0%

0.0%

2.9%

BasedBot

5.7%

0.0%

0.0%

4.4%

Uniswap

6.2%

3.1%

0.0%

7.3%

Maestro

8.3%

5.6%

0.0%

6.7%

Sigma

10.3%

4.4%

1.5%

10.4%

Banana Gun

13.2%

8.8%

4.4%

69.3%


🚧 What Competitors Cost You

Extra capital lost compared to Altcoinist at various trading volumes.

Your Volume

Maestro

MetaMask

BasedBot

Sigma

Uniswap

Banana Gun

$10,000

-$13

-$31

-$67

-$88

-$217

-$283

$50,000

-$65

-$155

-$335

-$440

-$1,085

-$1,415

$100,000

-$130

-$310

-$670

-$880

-$2,170

-$2,830

$500,000

-$650

-$1,550

-$3,350

-$4,400

-$10,850

-$14,150

$1,000,000

-$1,300

-$3,100

-$6,700

-$8,800

-$21,700

-$28,300


📈 Sell Execution: Where Altcoinist Shines Brightest

Taking profits matters. This is what you’re losing when exiting a position…

Platform

Sell Execution Loss

vs Altcoinist

Altcoinist

0.04%

Baseline (nearly perfect)

Maestro

0.21%

5x worse

Uniswap

0.32%

8x worse

BasedBot

0.42%

10x worse

MetaMask

0.59%

15x worse

Sigma

0.73%

18x worse

Banana Gun

3.95%

99x worse


🎯 Consistency: Predictable Results, Every Trade

How much does execution quality vary from trade to trade? Higher score = more predictable.

Platform

Consistency Score

Interpretation

Altcoinist

100/100

Most predictable

MetaMask

79/100

Good

BasedBot

49/100

Variable

Uniswap

47/100

Unpredictable

Maestro

41/100

Variable

Sigma

31/100

Very unpredictable

Banana Gun

8/100

Extremely erratic


🚧 Routing Failures: Trades Competitors Couldn't Complete

Some platforms simply can't execute certain trades.

Platform

Failed Trade

What Happened

Uniswap

EDGE SELL 0.5 ETH

Would have lost 64% — skipped to avoid catastrophic loss

Sigma

EDGE BUY 0.5 ETH

16% price impact — marked invalid, couldn't route

Altcoinist

All trades completed successfully ✓


⏲️ Speed vs Execution: The Trade-off

Fast bots prioritize speed. Smart bots prioritize your wallet.

Platform

Approach

Execution Score

The Reality

Fast Bots

Rush to block

6-22/100

Speed, but massive capital leak

Altcoinist

Smart routing

100/100

Seconds longer = thousands saved


🏆 Who Should Use Altcoinist?

Active daily traders — Savings compound dramatically at volume

Large position traders — Execution quality advantage scales with trade size

Dollar-cost averaging strategies — Consistent savings on regular buys

Long-term holders — Better entry/exit prices = better returns

MEV-sensitive traders — Lower slippage = less MEV extraction

Profit-takers — Near-perfect sell execution (+0.04%)

Not ideal for: Arbitrage traders, front-running strategies, pool snipers


💎 The Altcoinist Advantage

  1. Smart routing — Finds the best liquidity across multiple sources via Definitive.fi

  2. Stealth Trading — Avoids wallet trackers & front-runners with untraceable trades

  3. Near-perfect sells — +0.04% execution loss on sells (99x better than worst competitor)

  4. Zero catastrophic trades — 0% of trades over 3% execution loss

  5. MEV resistance — Better execution = less value leaked to MEV

  6. Predictable results — Highest consistency score of any platform


🖊️ Summary

Metric

Altcoinist

Competitor Range

Altcoinist Advantage

Execution Score

100/100

6-59/100

2-16x better

Win Rate

74%

24-67%

+7 to +50% higher

Catastrophic Loss Rate (3%+)

0%

0-13.2%

Zero bad trades

Sell Execution

+0.04%

+0.21% to +3.95%

5-99x better

Consistency

100/100

8-79/100

Most predictable

Failed Trades

0

Multiple

Wider DEX support

At $100K Volume

vs Competitor

Extra You Keep with Altcoinist

vs Maestro

+$130

vs MetaMask

+$310

vs BasedBot

+$670

vs Sigma

+$880

vs Uniswap

+$2,170

vs Banana Gun

+$2,830


✅ Data Transparency

Test Periods

Period

Dates

Platforms

Trade Sizes

Trades

November 2025

Nov 25-27

Altcoinist, Maestro, Sigma, BasedBot, Banana Gun

0.01, 0.05, 0.2 ETH

179

December 2025

Dec 13-23

Altcoinist, Uniswap, MetaMask, Sigma, BasedBot, Banana Gun

0.05, 0.1, 0.5 ETH

232

Altcoinist Performance Over Time

Period

Execution Loss

Trades

November 2025

+0.03%

36

December 2025

+0.37%

32

Combined

+0.19%

68

Consistent performance across different market conditions.

Based on 400+ independent trades over 2 months.

Full data available for verification.

Available here → Competitor Test Databases

Test conducted November 2025. Performance data verified. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Trading involves risk.


Get More Tokens, Every Trade – Start Now & Claim 50% Cashback Offer

Last updated